Landmark Judgment Affirms Eligibility for 'Outstanding Sports Person' Category Regardless of State Representation
Jaipur, May 21, 2026 – In a significant judgment delivered by the Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, Justice Anand Sharma ruled in favor of Mamta Kumari, affirming her eligibility for reservation under the 'Outstanding Sports Person' category despite representing a university outside Rajasthan. The decision, which quashes an earlier order denying her appointment, underscores the principle that participation in recognized sports tournaments qualifies candidates, irrespective of the state they represent.
The case revolved around Mamta Kumari's participation in an All India Inter-University Tournament, recognized by the Association of Indian Universities. Despite her bonafide residence in Rajasthan, her eligibility was contested because she represented the State of Haryana during the tournament. The court clarified that the statutory provisions do not mandate representation of Rajasthan alone for eligibility, emphasizing that eligibility is tied to participation in the tournament itself.
Justice Sharma highlighted that restrictive interpretations of the eligibility clause would undermine the literal and plain meaning of the statute, thereby denying legitimate rights to candidates. The judgment also addressed the conflict between circulars issued by the Elementary Education Department and statutory notifications under Article 309 of the Constitution, asserting that circulars cannot override statutory provisions.
The judgment aligns with previous rulings, including the case of Imran Khan v. State of Rajasthan, reinforcing the stance that residency and participation in recognized events are the key criteria for reservation under the sports category. This ruling directs the respondents to issue Mamta Kumari's appointment order within 60 days, ensuring her rightful place as Teacher Grade III Level II (Maths-Science).
The court’s decision is expected to impact similar cases, promoting inclusivity and encouraging sports talent across states without geographical bias. The ruling serves as a reminder to administrative bodies to adhere to judicial directions and statutory provisions, fostering a fair and just system for sports participants in Rajasthan.
Bottom line:-
Reservation under 'Outstanding Sports Person' category - Eligibility is attached to participation in a recognized tournament, not to the State represented by the candidate. Circulars cannot override statutory provisions or notifications under Article 309 of the Constitution.
Statutory provision(s): Article 309 of the Constitution, Notifications under the Department of Personnel, Rajasthan, Circular dated 08.01.2020, Rules for 'Outstanding Sports Person' category.
Mamta Kumari v. State of Rajasthan, (Rajasthan)(Jaipur Bench) : Law Finder Doc id # 2915359
